From the comments on my last post I learned I have 3 regular readers, which is actually one more than I thought I had. I guess I will keep shelling out to my hosting provider for the benefit of the three of you.
The Wall Street Journal just posted an article called How the Office Became the Worst Place to Actually Do Work (paywall). I’m really happy someone is noticing! I’ve often thought that the move to open office spaces may be correlated to the crappiness of products vendors release. I know, correlation is not causation, but my own experience tells me it’s true, and what’s data but a collection of anedcotes?
When I worked at Cisco TAC, I had a cubicle, but my teammates and I knocked parts of the walls out so we could see each other. There was little privacy but we didn’t need it. We were a tight team. Our bosses rarely ventured into our area, and when they did they were not likely to look over our shoulder and tell us we were running the wrong show command. We were constantly bouncing ideas off of each other and borrowing each other’s expertise.
The last time I had a really good office setup was back when I worked for a gold partner in downtown San Francisco. I had an office with floor-to-ceiling windows, a giant mahogany desk with cabinets, a massive white board, and a round side table I could use to meet with people. As a consultant I was hardly there, but when I was, I could focus and get work done.
I got laid off from that place pretty quickly, and ended up at Juniper. As a director, I was given an office. It had no windows at all, and looked like it might be more suited to a prison. But it had a door I could close, so when I needed to think or do deep work I could shut it and be left in peace.
That lasted until I got demoted and booted down to a lower pay grade (sheesh, bad things happen to me I guess). I was bumped out and sent back into a cubicle. I was actually fine with the cubicle. It afforded enough privacy that I could focus on my work and yet I felt more connected to my team. Then, Juniper moved us to a new building which had waist high cubes. I hated it. We all did. There was no privacy, no hiding, and everything you did was visible to others. Then, they moved us again into another building where we just had a desk out in the open. I felt like Milton in Office Space, getting pushed around by unaccountable bosses.
I felt so exposed working on anything there that I couldn’t concentrate. My wife says I worry too much what other people think of me, and I cannot dispute that. When I have a document open and the world can see it, and it’s a “work-in-progress”, I can’t focus at all. Back then I used to take the train to work, and so I had no car at the office. I’d show up and take a meeting or two, and then take the light rail a few stops away to a coffee shop where I would sit with my back to the wall and earphones in, to do “deep work”.
When I came back to Cisco, I was overjoyed to have a cube again. It didn’t last, however, as we were moved to a newly revamped building which just had a sea of desks. When we got there I joked with my coworkers that the walls of the toilet stalls had also been removed to foster team spirit. Some of them seemed to believe me.
I drive to Cisco, so I know which buildings are the least inhabited. When I need to focus, I actually drive to one of them and grab a small room. Why not just stay in my own building? Too crowded, too noisy, and too hard to find a room. The rooms all have glass, anyways, so I’m still likely to be seen. And I hate to take up a room, just for myself, that is meant for meetings. You sit in the room and then groups of two or three people peer resentfully while you occupy a needed room.
Seemingly aware of this problem, the designers of our first cubeless building added a “play” area to help stimulate our innovative juices. It was stocked with all sorts of legos, blocks, games, and a variety of tools and materials to be used for constructing…you know…innovative things. You see, if you got your master’s in interior design, you have no idea what network engineers actually do, but you know they are…innovators…and innovators need to play, right? To innovate! They’re creative!

It turns out that in five years I never once saw any employee use our play area. A couple times I saw people’s kids over there. Eventually the tools all got stolen and the play area was torn down.
Anyways, play areas aside, the open office space has been disastrous for so many reasons. There is the noise, there is the constant hunting for rooms, there is the lack of privacy, there is the feeling of being watched, constantly. I heard we were going to be asked to come in four days a week. Fine, but almost immediately after I show up to work I go to another building or a coffee shop and actually focus without distractions.
All of these factors sap productivity and concentration. While I think there are a lot of factors that go in to vendors producing bad products (the rise of MBAs, the perverse incentives of Wall Street, the ongoing attempt to end expertise), I wonder if sending people into vast oceans of unseparated desks might have something to do with it. I’m glad someone is calling it out, I just hope someone will do something about it.